Eurovision (ESC) Thursday - ESC22 Then & Now - Part 1

I figured that I would do a comparison of what I thought about the songs when they were first released and what I think about the songs now since we are about 1.5 weeks away from the big day. Keep in mind for my “now”, I’m factoring in several things – preparty performances, general personality, and of course the song.

Since there are 40 countries competing in this year’s Eurovision Song Contest, I’m breaking this topic down into two parts. Here’s the first half of the list in alphabetical order by country.

ALBANIA – RONELA – “SEKRET”

 
 

OMG, she pretty much embodies everything that makes Eurovision great. I would even say that is the most well-rounded artist in the contest. If there was some sort of Miss Congeniality award for Eurovision, she would be my top choice.

ARMENIA – ROSA LINN – “SNAP”

 
 

AUSTRALIA – SHELDON RILEY – “NOT THE SAME”

 
 

I’m not really sure why, but Sheldon lost power with me over the past couple of months.

AUSTRIA – LUM!X & PIA MARIA – “HALO”

 
 

Kind of like the song, but I was kind of surprised that Pia Maria’s live vocals were not as strong as they were on the studio version (I guess this happens frequently). My three stars are pretty much based on the song along because it’s one of those songs that will get you dancing or bopping your head at least.

AZERBAIJAN – NADIR RUSTAMLI – “FADE TO BLACK”

 
 

I will admit that I originally thought this song was a snoozefest. Like I said earlier, I think I was all Eurovisioned out by the time Azerbaijan released this song. That said, the song has grown on me and Nadir seems like a fun individual to hang with. In some ways, he reminds me a little bit of someone I used to date . . . even down to his “gingerness”

BELGIUM – JÉRÉMIE MAKIESE – “MISS YOU”

 
 

I think he is one of the strongest male vocalists in the contest, and I am a fan of the strong R&B vibe of the song. That said, I do not know much about him. He hasn’t been as active as other performers so it’s tough to get a sense of who he is. I wonder if it’s an English language thing for him. For instance, I’m not sure if he feels comfortable enough with the English language to put himself out there in these ESC streets. I fear that this might hurt him in the contest. But then again, most ESC viewers do not really pay attention to the contest until semi and final week.

BULGARIA – INTELLIGENT MUSIC PROJECT

 
 

I have to admit, I think that I let the public opinion influence my original thoughts about the song. While the song is a bit dated, I do not think it’s THAT bad of a song. Actually, the song has made it onto a couple of my running playlists.

CROATIA – MIA DIMŠIĆ – “GUILTY PLEASURE”

 
 

Eh, my opinion has not really changed too much.

CYPRUS – ANDROMACHE – “ELA”

 
 

Another case of loving the song but not knowing much about the artist. It seems like she is not too invested in ESC2022, which is fine. I assume that some artists would rather focus on themselves, their songs, their staging, etc during the weeks leading to Eurovision. She had a couple of interviews that gave me a bit of an “oh that’s weird” vibe. In an interview, she was asked about Greece’s ESC2022 song, and she said that she hadn’t heard it. As most know, Greece and Cyprus are pretty much cousins in this contest because they tend to give each other high points. Also, she (like most folks from Cyprus) is Greek. I dunno, but it seems strange that she (at this point) has not heard the Greek song. In another interview, she was asked if she’d be willing to do a collaboration with Chanel (Spain). This question was asked because a lot of folks from Spain like her song. And she responded that she did not know who Chanel is. I’m not mad that she does not know Chanel. BUT, for ESC2022, if you were to ask someone to name five artists from this batch, most folks would say (in no particular order) – Chanel (Spain), Ronela (Albania), Mahmmod & BLANCO (Italy), Ochman (Poland), and Sam Ryder (the UK). So it’s kind of strange that she responded in that manner. Then again, maybe she meant more of an I do not know her personally as opposed to not knowing who she is.

CZECH REPUBLIC – WE ARE DOMI – “LIGHTS OFF”

 
 

Going into the season this was one of my top songs. After seeing the group’s performances in the preparties, I was surprised by the weak vocals compared to the studio version and the Czech Republic’s national selection. Ok, the five preparties’ venues had a lot of issues with sound and technical difficulties. That said, other performers did fine with the same difficulties.

DENMARK – REDDI – “THE SHOW”

 
 

ESTONIA – STEFAN – “HOPE”

 
 

I still really like the song and the performer. While this song was released early in the national selection season, it pretty much has stayed in my top ten since it was released.

FINLAND – THE RASMUS – “JEZEBEL”

 
 

Right now, the song just really does not do much for me, but maybe that will change once I see the band on stage. I will say that out of all of the national finals, this band had the best LED staging.

FRANCE – ALVAN & AHEZ – “FULENN”

 
 

After viewing France’s national selection, this group was one of my tops. However, the group’s performances during the preparties leading up to ESC2022 week have been less than stellar. In my opinion, Alvan (one artist) and Ahez (a female trio) have not been really cohesive in some of their live performances. For instance, it sounds like they are singing two to three different songs even though they are now one group. While I like the song, I feel that the women in Ahez do not have a commanding stage presence, which is a huge contrast while looking at Alvan jumping all around the stage.

GERMANY – MALIK HARRIS – “ROCKSTARS”

 
 

This one has lost a bit of power for me. The other day, I was thinking about the songs from the Big 5 (France, Germany, Italy, Spain, and the UK) and completely forgot about Germany’s entry. Like, I actually had to think very hard to remember the song and the artist. While the other members of the Big 5 put up strong entries this year, I think Germany is the weakest of the group. Since Germany is part of the Big 5, Malik will automatically qualify for the final; however, I do not see a strong finish for him. At the end of the day, I’m not sure that Rockstars is a good song for Eurovision, but I have a feeling that it will make it into some of my chillin’ at home playlists.

GREECE – AMANDA TENFJORD – “DIE TOGETHER”

 
 

I have no words that reflect how much I enjoy listening to this song.

ICELAND – SYSTUR – “MEÐ HÆKKANDI SÓL”

 
 

This trio definitely has grown one me over the past couple of months. While it might be a long shot, I really hope that they will qualify for the final. I wonder if they plan to include some English in this song as a way to connect to a larger audience.

IRELAND – BROOKE SCULLION – “THAT’S RICH”

 
 

Originally, this song was not my cup of tea (actually, it’s still not my cup of tea). However, I am quite impressed that Brooke’s vocals (and performances) have drastically improved over the past couple of months. Depending on her staging, I think the song might have a shot at qualifying. LOL moment for Brooke (maybe now it’s an LOL moment). When traveling from Ireland to Spain for one of the preparties, she lost her passport and had trouble entering the country. There’s video of officials in Spain’s border control office viewing her videos as a form of identifying her.

ISRAEL – MICHAEL BEN DAVID – “I.M”

 
 

Actually, I think my rating now would be a 2.5, but I guess that I gotta round up. The song just does not work for me as much as it did when was first released. However, word on the ESC streets has been saying that his rehearsal staging is really good and elevates his song and performance.

My Complete Rankings

 
 






Eurovision Song Contest (ESC) – Israel 🇮🇱

Michael Ben David – I.M

 
 

Vocal:

I don’t know. It’s probably me, but he sounds pretty pitchy and strained in certain parts of the song. I think the strained BAAAAAAABYYYYY within the first moments of the song kind of made me lose interest. Since this happened right at the beginning of the song, perhaps he was experiencing some nerves. Then again, I am a fan of building up the vocal as the song progresses – don’t be starting off the song screaming.

Musical Arrangement:

While I like the overall message and composition of the song, it sounded pretty general. You know, like something that would be performed at an LGBT bar or drag queen brunch. Case in point, Michael’s song sounds a lot like Bilal Hassani’s (ESC 2019, France) song, Basic – https://youtu.be/dODJK9SNbMs.

Staging:

In terms of the lighting, pyro, and dancing/choreo, I think the song is pretty much Eurovision-ready. Also, being on a bigger stage in Turnin more than likely will enhance all of the fun and cool staging effects. BTW, I love the little dance break around 1:53. I really enjoy that many of the Israeli artists incorporate some middle eastern sounds into their performances for Eurovision. Even though most performers do not sing in one of their countries’ national languages, I appreciate it when they incorporate some themes from their regions of the world.

Final Thoughts:

 
 

While I’m not a huge fan of the singer’s voice, the singer has a great stage presence and the song oozes a great deal of confidence (which can be a good or bad thing). I feel that the performance with the dancers and lighting effects saves the overall vocal. I think that the public vote will bring it to the final, but the national juries may not give it high marks, which might hurt it in the final.

Israel in last year’s Eurovision:

Eden Alene – Set Me Free

  • Semi-final results: 5th place out of 16 performances (192 total points – 99 national juries and 93 public votes)

  • Final results: 17th place out of 26 performances (93 total points – 73 national juries and 20 public votes)

 
 

I gotta say that I was a bit shocked with Eden’s placement in the finals because I was sure that she was going to be in the top ten. I mean, the performance had it all – a strong vocal, decent dancing, nice staging, a fabulous hairstyle. Random trivia: Eden hit the highest note in the history of Eurovision. Honestly, I thought her performance was a lot better than some of the other acts that placed higher. I think her placement was affected by a couple of factors that were out of her control.

  • The running order: I believe Eden was 3rd in the running order, which meant that she performed in the first half of the contest. I think this order might have hurt her with the public vote especially in the mix of so many pop songs by other Eurodivas.

  • Political voting: During Eurovision (May 21), Israel was involved in a military back and forth with Palestine, which may have soured the public toward Israel, not Eden. It probably did not help to have a song called Set Me Free while engaged in such a military back forth. In Israel’s defense, the song was submitted in March before the Israeli-Palestine tensions. Had Eden completed for another country, I think that she would have placed higher in this ESC2021. In fact, for Eurovision 2019 (see below), several acts expressed their concerns over the contest being held in Tel Aviv.

 

Image courtesy of The Times of Israel

 

I thought it was a bit disgusting that the Iceland performers held up a Free Palestine message during the voting segment of the contest. It’s fine to have your opinion, but these types of political messages should stay out of competitions like this.